GLI GLI Quality Tool
GLI Quality Tool — Version 2.0

How to conduct a mock TB lab accreditation survey with GLI checklists

A mock accreditation survey gives a tuberculosis laboratory a practical way to test its quality management system before an external assessment. Rather than treating the exercise as a document review, the laboratory should recreate the conditions of an accreditation visit: assessors follow evidence, interview staff, observe work, and compare routine practice with written procedures.

The GLI Quality Tool supports this process through a four-phase improvement roadmap organized around twelve Quality Systems Essentials. Its checklists help laboratories examine safety, personnel, equipment, documents, purchasing, process control, assessment, and continual improvement in a structured way that can be adapted to different resource settings.

The strongest simulation is fair, evidence-based, and focused on patient and staff safety. It should reveal gaps in daily practice without turning the exercise into an inspection designed to assign blame. Results are most useful when they lead to assigned corrective actions, realistic deadlines, and a second review.

Define the scope and survey team

Begin by deciding what the mock survey will cover. A laboratory preparing for an initial accreditation assessment may review all twelve Quality Systems Essentials, while a laboratory maintaining recognition may focus on findings from its last assessment, newly introduced testing methods, or high-risk areas such as biosafety and result reporting.

Select a survey team that is independent enough to provide an objective view. A quality manager can coordinate the exercise, but should not be the only reviewer of their own records. Include a senior technologist, a biosafety representative, and, where possible, a peer from another laboratory or an external quality adviser. Assign one person to record evidence and another to manage interviews and observations.

Share the purpose, schedule, and boundaries with staff in advance, but avoid giving individual reviewers a script of expected answers. Staff should understand that the exercise evaluates processes rather than personal worth. The survey team should also agree on how it will classify findings, such as critical, major, minor, or compliant, before activities begin.

Convert GLI checklists into an assessment plan

Use the relevant GLI phase checklist as the backbone of the survey. Read each requirement as an assessment question: Is the process defined? Is it implemented consistently? Can the laboratory show objective evidence? Is the process reviewed and improved? This approach prevents a file-heavy review from overlooking what actually happens at the bench.

Build a survey schedule that follows the laboratory workflow. A typical sequence includes an opening meeting, facility tour, document review, observation of testing, interviews with staff, review of records, and a closing discussion. Include pre-analytical, analytical, and post-analytical activities so that specimen reception, testing, result authorization, referral, and waste handling are all visible.

For every checklist item, identify likely evidence in advance. Evidence may include an approved SOP, revision history, equipment maintenance log, temperature chart, competency assessment, internal quality control record, incident report, corrective action file, or management review. Mark each item as compliant, partially compliant, or non-compliant only after comparing the written requirement with actual evidence.

Observe routine work and verify records

A mock survey should include direct observation during normal operations. Watch how staff receive and identify specimens, confirm test requests, use personal protective equipment, perform procedures, record results, handle errors, and dispose of infectious waste. Avoid interrupting unless an immediate safety risk requires action. The goal is to see the routine process, including workarounds that may not appear in an SOP.

Equipment checks deserve close attention because small omissions can affect testing quality. Review whether staff perform checks at the required frequency, record the results clearly, and escalate problems when equipment is outside acceptable limits. A practical daily equipment checklist can help make these checks consistent without creating unnecessary paperwork.

Use a sample of records rather than accepting a single perfect example. Select documents from different weeks, shifts, staff members, and testing platforms. Compare dates, signatures, corrective actions, and follow-up evidence. If the laboratory reports results electronically, verify that access controls, audit trails, backup arrangements, and amended reports are addressed.

Survey area Evidence to review Observation or interview prompt Typical warning sign
Laboratory safety Risk assessment, training records, incident log, waste records Ask staff to explain spill and exposure procedures Staff rely on memory or outdated instructions
Personnel Job descriptions, competency files, duty roster Observe a task and discuss authorization limits Training is recorded but competency is not demonstrated
Equipment Inventory, maintenance files, calibration records, daily checks Ask what happens when equipment fails Missing service dates or unresolved breakdowns
Documents and records SOP master list, controlled copies, forms, revisions Compare the bench copy with the approved version Staff use uncontrolled or obsolete documents
Testing process Internal quality control, EQA results, worksheets, reports Trace one specimen from receipt to result Gaps in identification, review, or result release
Assessment and improvement Audit reports, nonconformities, action plans, management review Ask how recurring problems are analyzed Corrective actions are closed without effectiveness checks

Interview staff and test the system

Interviews should test understanding rather than invite rehearsed statements. Ask staff to describe what they do when a control fails, a specimen is unsuitable, a result must be amended, or a critical instrument becomes unavailable. Then verify their answers against the procedure and recent records.

Include staff from different roles and shifts, including reception, testing, reporting, cleaning, and supervision. A quality system is credible only when its requirements are understood across the workflow. Pay particular attention to temporary, newly assigned, or cross-trained personnel, because their records may reveal weaknesses in induction and authorization.

Technical competence can be explored through observation, record review, and peer review. For smear microscopy, a structured peer observation program provides evidence that reading accuracy is monitored in a supportive and repeatable way. The survey should verify that observation findings lead to coaching or retraining when needed, rather than being filed without action.

Do not treat an incorrect answer as an automatic nonconformity. Determine whether the staff member misunderstood an isolated detail, whether the procedure is unclear, or whether the laboratory has a broader training and supervision problem. Record the exact evidence and assess the risk to test validity, biosafety, or patient care.

Rate findings and identify root causes

At the end of each review, write findings in clear, factual language. State the requirement, describe the evidence, and explain the risk or consequence. “Temperature records for the reagent refrigerator were missing on seven of twenty sampled days” is more useful than “refrigerator monitoring is poor.” Avoid naming individuals when the issue concerns a system.

Separate isolated errors from systemic nonconformities. A missing signature may require a reminder, while repeated gaps across several records may indicate an ineffective review process. A critical finding should be reserved for a condition that creates an immediate or substantial threat to staff safety, specimen integrity, result validity, or patient management.

Use root-cause analysis for important findings. Ask whether the cause involves unclear responsibility, insufficient resources, inadequate training, poor document control, equipment failure, workload, or weak supervision. The corrective action should address that cause. Replacing a form will not solve a problem caused by missing review or unclear authority.

At the closing meeting, present strengths as well as gaps. Explain which findings need immediate containment and which can enter a planned improvement cycle. Obtain agreement on the wording, but do not dilute evidence-based findings simply to make the results more comfortable.

Turn findings into an improvement cycle

Prepare a corrective action plan soon after the simulation. Each action should have an owner, due date, required resources, and a measurable completion criterion. For example, “update SOP” is incomplete; a stronger action specifies approval of the revised SOP, removal of obsolete copies, staff briefing, and a competency check using the revised process.

Prioritize actions by risk and dependency. Immediate hazards, unreliable results, and failures affecting critical reporting should come first. Some improvements may require procurement, staffing changes, or regional support, so record interim controls while longer-term solutions are arranged.

Track effectiveness, not just completion. After an action is marked finished, sample records again, repeat an observation, or review trend data after several weeks. If the problem persists, reopen the finding and revise the corrective action. This makes the mock survey part of continual improvement rather than a one-time rehearsal.

Use the final report as a baseline for the next GLI phase review. Keep the completed checklist, evidence references, findings, action plan, and follow-up results together. Repeating targeted surveys at planned intervals helps the laboratory demonstrate sustained implementation and prepares staff for the evidence-based nature of an external accreditation assessment.

Practical recommendations for a credible mock survey

A well-run simulation gives the laboratory more than a predicted accreditation result. It shows whether policies are understood, whether records can support claims, and whether staff can respond safely when routine processes fail. Download the appropriate GLI materials, appoint a cross-functional survey team, and begin with a focused review of the highest-risk checklist areas before expanding to the full quality management system.